Endowment effect test

Description

Measures how much more users value something once they own it, by comparing willingness to accept giving it up with willingness to pay to acquire it.

In Kahneman, Knetsch and Thaler's experiments, owners of a coffee mug demanded roughly twice what non-owners would pay for it. The endowment effect explains why users resist giving up configured settings, saved data, legacy plans or familiar workflows, and why trials, customisation and early ownership cues raise retention. The test randomly endows some participants with an item (a plan, a feature, a data asset, a design they built) and compares the price or effort they require to give it up with what non-endowed participants would pay or do to get it. A ratio of willingness to accept to willingness to pay well above 1 indicates endowment. Rigour comes from random assignment of ownership, incentive-compatible elicitation such as the Becker-DeGroot-Marschak mechanism, and controls for information differences.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Design, Strategy
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Choose the good to test: a feature, plan, saved configuration, content library or self-made artefact, and define how ownership is created (granted, trialled or self-built).
  2. Randomly assign 40 to 100 participants per condition to owner and non-owner conditions, ensuring both groups receive identical information about the good.
  3. Elicit willingness to accept from owners and willingness to pay from non-owners using an incentive-compatible method such as Becker-DeGroot-Marschak, or a realistic equivalent like choosing between keeping the good and a credit amount.
  4. Compute the median WTA/WTP ratio with a bootstrap 95% confidence interval and test the difference with a Mann-Whitney U test.
  5. Add a variant that varies ownership duration or effort invested (for example 1 day versus 14 days of trial, or a template versus a self-built item) to estimate how endowment grows.
  6. Apply results to design decisions about trials, migration paths, downgrades and customisation, and check them against observed retention.

Sources

  • Prospect Theory works (Kahneman/Tversky)
  • Nash Equilibrium in UX (Gopinath)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 23 — Reference Points, Prospect Theory & the Mechanics of Satisfaction

Also known as

  • WTA-WTP gap test
  • Ownership effect test
  • Mere ownership test

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Behavioral Science & Economics