Description
Scores an experience at each level of a hierarchy, functional, reliable, usable and pleasurable, ensuring lower levels are secure before investing in delight.
Walter's emotional design hierarchy adapts Maslow's needs hierarchy to products: an experience must first be functional (it works), then reliable (it works consistently), then usable (people can use it easily), and only then pleasurable (people enjoy it and form an emotional connection). Most teams stop at usable, while others add delight to flows that are not yet reliable, which backfires. As a scoring method, each key flow is rated at each level using evidence: defect and error logs for functional and reliability, usability metrics for usable, and affect measures (for example semantic differentials, emotional response cards or sentiment in feedback) for pleasurable. The result is a profile showing where investment should go. It pairs with aesthetic-usability effect measurement to prevent pleasure masking usability problems.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Usability & Evaluation
- Loss type
- Latent
- Goal
- Prioritise, Evaluate usability
- Stage
- Evaluation
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Audit the current design against the hierarchy: score each level (1–5).
- Calculate: what is the minimum score at each level?
- Focus improvement where the lowest level falls below 3.
- Once lower levels score ≥ 4, invest in the next level.
- For emotional design: identify three peak moments in the user journey (first use, achievement, recovery from error) and design each to produce a specific positive emotion.
Sources
- Designing for Emotion — Aarron Walter
- Well Designed (Kolko)
- 100 Things Every Designer Should Know (Weinschenk)
- Emotional Design (Donald Norman)
- Maslow, A theory of human motivation (Psychological Review, 1943)
- Designing for Emotion (Walter)
- The Inquiry Series, Ch 36 — Emotional Design Hierarchies & the Aesthetic-Usability Effect
Also known as
- Emotional design hierarchy (Maslow for UX)
- Functional-reliable-usable-pleasurable audit
Categories
- User Research
- Usability & Evaluation