Emergent Mixed Methods Design (Following a Thread)

Description

Let the design change substantially during a study when one strand produces discordant or surprising results, and pursue the surprise with new data or analysis in the other strand.

A mixed methods design is emergent when iterative dialogue between strands leads to substantial changes in conceptualisation, sampling, data collection or analysis. It may be planned as emergent, with flexibility agreed upfront, or become so. Triggers include new questions, new data sources, unexpected findings in the other strand and stakeholder requests. Following a thread, from Moran-Ellis and colleagues, is the core move: take a discordant finding from one strand and pursue it with new hypotheses and analyses in the other, rather than reporting it as a limitation. In a Malawi maternal health evaluation, a survey showed no rise in service use while health workers reported more work; the team added facility records and followed the thread to referral patterns and maternal mortality. Only substantial changes count, not tweaks, and each change is documented with its rationale. The risk is sprawl, so budgets and approvals must allow flexibility.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Plan for possible emergence and explain it to sponsors, ethics boards and stakeholders upfront.
  2. At each stage, watch for triggers: new questions, new data sources, unexpected findings in the other strand, stakeholder requests.
  3. When strands disagree, select the discordant result as a thread to follow.
  4. Add a component, data source or sample, or change the analysis or integration point, to pursue it.
  5. Document each change, its trigger and its rationale.
  6. Integrate the findings and report how the design evolved and why.

Sources

  • The Sage Handbook of Mixed Methods Research Design (Poth, 2023)

Also known as

  • Follow-the-thread
  • Emergent design
  • Following a thread

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor