Description
Interrogates whether folk-psychological constructs such as user intention, goal and mental model are valid units of analysis, prompting operational definitions and behavioural evidence.
Eliminative materialism argues that folk psychology, the everyday vocabulary of beliefs, desires and intentions, is a theory that may be false and could be replaced by a mature neuroscience. Whatever its philosophical merits, it raises a practical question for UX research: constructs such as 'user intention', 'goal' and 'mental model' are folk concepts that researchers often treat as directly observable. The method is a construct audit. For each such construct in a study, the researcher states its operational definition, what evidence would indicate it (verbal reports, choices, eye movements, errors), and whether different measures converge. Where they do not, findings are reframed in terms of observed behaviour and predictions. This improves construct validity and guards against reifying participants' after-the-fact explanations as causes.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Stage
- Definition
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Apply eliminative skepticism to UX research constructs: for each construct used in research ('the user intended to...', 'the user's mental model is...'), ask:
- is this construct operationalized in behavior, or inferred?
- (2) would different explanatory constructs (neural, computational, behavioral) better predict the phenomenon? Use behavioral measures (response time, error pattern, eye movement) alongside inferential mental-model constructs.
Sources
- Neurophilosophy — Patricia Smith Churchland
- Churchland PM, Eliminative materialism and the propositional attitudes (Journal of Philosophy, 1981)
Also known as
- Folk psychology critique in UX
- Construct validity audit of mental-model terms
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor