Elimination by Aspects in Interface Choice Design

Description

Models how users choose by eliminating options that fail on the most important attribute in turn, guiding design of comparison, filtering and plan-selection interfaces.

Elimination by aspects is a non-compensatory choice model: rather than weighing all attributes, decision makers select an attribute (with probability proportional to its importance), eliminate options lacking it, and repeat until one option remains. Strengths on other attributes cannot compensate for failing an early cut. Consumer research uses it to explain filtering behaviour and choice overload. For interface design, the model predicts that users facing many options will screen on a few key aspects, so comparison tables, filters and pricing pages should expose the aspects people eliminate on first and in the right order. The method elicits elimination sequences through process tracing (think-aloud, information boards, filter logs) and fits attribute weights, distinguishing compensatory from lexicographic strategies.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Design
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify first-elimination attributes through interview: 'What would make you immediately reject this option?' Surface that attribute first and most prominently.

Sources

  • Preference, Belief, and Similarity — Amos Tversky
  • Tversky, Elimination by aspects: A theory of choice (Psychological Review, 1972)
  • Payne, Bettman & Johnson, The Adaptive Decision Maker (1993)

Also known as

  • EBA
  • Lexicographic choice analysis
  • Non-compensatory choice modelling

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Game Theory & Decision Science