Eidetic variation

Description

Identifies the essential structure of an experience by imaginatively varying its features and noting which changes would make it no longer the same kind of experience.

Husserl proposed that the essence of a phenomenon can be found by freely varying its features in imagination: if a feature can be removed or changed and the experience remains the same kind of experience, it is contingent; if changing it destroys the experience, it is essential. In empirical phenomenology, the researcher applies this to participants' descriptions. For example, in the experience of 'submitting a claim and waiting', is uncertainty about receipt essential, or would a confirmed receipt leave the experience intact? This distinguishes invariant structures from incidental details of particular cases. For UX it offers a disciplined way to decide what a design must address and what can vary. Rigour comes from systematic variation of each constituent, documented reasoning, and checking variations against actual participant accounts.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Start from a set of rich first-person descriptions of the experience, typically 5 to 15 participants, already broken into meaning units.
  2. List candidate constituents of the experience, such as waiting, uncertainty, being judged, effort, and dependence on others.
  3. For each constituent, imagine it removed or radically altered and ask whether the experience would still be the same kind of experience, recording the reasoning.
  4. Check imagined variations against actual cases: do any participants' accounts lack the constituent while remaining the same experience?
  5. Classify constituents as essential (invariant) or contingent (variable), and describe how essential constituents relate to one another.
  6. Translate the essential structure into design requirements and the contingent features into acceptable design variation.

Sources

  • Fundamentals of Qualitative Research
  • Sage Handbook of Qualitative Data Collection (Flick)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 30 — Phenomenological Methods — The Structure of Lived Experience

Also known as

  • Free imaginative variation
  • Imaginative variation
  • Eidetic reduction

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis