Description
Distinguishes what participants explicitly say from the implicit, taken-for-granted orientations their way of talking reveals, using formulating and reflecting interpretation plus systematic comparison.
The Documentary Method of Interpretation (Ralf Bohnsack, developed from Karl Mannheim's sociology of knowledge) distinguishes between two levels of meaning: the communicative meaning (what is explicitly said or shown) and the documentary meaning (the implicit orientations, habitual practices, and taken-for-granted frameworks that are enacted in communication without being directly said). The method has been applied to interview data, group discussions, and visual data. It is particularly valuable for UX research where the explicit content of what users say differs systematically from what their behaviour and interaction reveals about their underlying orientations.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Goal
- Understand why
- Stage
- Discovery, Definition
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Formulaic interpretation: Identify the topic — what is explicitly communicated? Paraphrase without interpretation.
- Reflective interpretation: How is the topic addressed? What is the mode of discussion — narrative, argumentation, description, evaluation? What does the form of expression reveal about the speaker's implicit orientation?
- Comparative analysis: Compare how different participants, groups, or interviews address the same topic. Where the topic is the same but the mode of addressing it differs, the difference reveals different orientations.
- Sinusoid of experience: Identify the arc of a topic discussion — when does it become animated? When does it go flat? Heightened engagement reveals what matters to participants at the level of orientation, not just stated preference.
- Validation through contrast: Validate your interpretation of a group's orientation by identifying contrast cases — groups or individuals who do not share that orientation. The contrast makes the orientation visible.
Sources
- Bohnsack — Documentary Method
- Handbook of Qualitative Methods (Flick)
- How to Analyse Interviews: A Documentary Method of Interpretation (arxiv)
Also known as
- Documentary method
- Bohnsack's documentary method
- Reconstructive analysis
Categories
- User Research
- Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis