Differential Susceptibility (Host Factor) Analysis

Description

Measures how harm from a UX pathogen varies by host factors (literacy, age, stress, disability, language, device) to target protection and expose inequity.

Epidemiology recognises that disease does not affect all hosts equally. The treatise lists UX host factors: digital literacy, cognitive load at interaction, emotional state and stress, time pressure, prior experience with the product or category, age and generational familiarity, language and culture, disability and accessibility needs, and socioeconomic factors affecting device and connectivity. Analysis estimates harm rates within strata and tests effect modification (interaction terms, stratified risk ratios), showing which groups bear disproportionate harm. In the roach motel case, susceptibility rose with time pressure and low literacy and fell after prior victimisation. The equity implication is central: UX pathogens inflict greater harm on users with less literacy, more pressure, minority backgrounds and disabilities.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Define the harm outcome and candidate host factors from theory and research.
  2. Collect outcome and host-factor data (surveys linked to logs, panel studies, experiments).
  3. Estimate harm rates by stratum with confidence intervals.
  4. Test effect modification with interaction models or stratified ratios.
  5. Identify high-susceptibility groups and mechanisms through qualitative follow-up.
  6. Design targeted protections and monitor their effect on disparities.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Rothman KJ, Greenland S & Lash TL (2008) Modern Epidemiology (effect modification)
  • Financial Conduct Authority (2021) FG21/1 Guidance on the fair treatment of vulnerable customers

Also known as

  • Host factor analysis
  • Effect modification analysis for UX harm
  • Vulnerability analysis

Categories

  • Epidemiology & Population Health