Description
A deviation-utility equation combining signal clarity, new and habitual utility, effort, trust, reward and norm pressure to predict whether users abandon a stabilised design form.
The Deviation Utility model operationalises Nash equilibrium for design adoption. Un is perceived utility of the new form, Uh the utility of the habitual form (safety, familiarity, symbolic capital), E the effort of transition, T trust in the new form, R the reward of transition, P the pressure of norms, and SNR the clarity with which the new form presents its value. SNR multiplies Un: if users cannot perceive value, its utility is effectively zero. The decision rule is ΔU < 0, the current form is stable; ΔU ≥ 0, transition becomes viable. Each term has paired instruments: Un and Uh on 0–10 Likert, E on 0–5 normalised (task time, error rate, NASA-TLX effort), T, R and P on 0–3 scales, and SNR as a 0–1 first-encounter recognition proportion. The model yields both a verdict and a diagnostic profile of dominant negative contributors. Limitations: components treated as independent and additive, and time dynamics not yet modelled.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Community-Proposed Frameworks
- Loss type
- Community-proposed
- Tested
- Not yet tested
- Stage
- Strategy, Definition
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Define the habitual form and the proposed new form, and the population whose adoption decision you are studying.
- Measure Un (usefulness ranking, semantic differential, 0–10) and Uh (old versus new preference tasks, 0–10), with think-aloud and interview probes ('Why do you return to the familiar form?').
- Measure E with task time, error rate and the NASA-TLX effort subscale (0–5 normalised), and T with a 3–5 item trust-in-artefact scale (0–3).
- Measure R as objective gain in time, cost or steps (0–3, with diary probes) and P with a reverse-scored social norm scale (0–3, 'What would your peers say if you changed?').
- Measure SNR as the proportion correctly identifying what the new form does on first encounter (0–1), optionally with eye-tracking dwell.
- Compute ΔU = (SNR × Un) − Uh − E + T + R − P and read the verdict (ΔU < 0 stable; ΔU ≥ 0 viable).
- Identify the dominant negative contributors, target interventions at them, and re-measure to test whether ΔU shifts toward positive.
Sources
- Vivek Gopinath (2025), Equilibrium and the Design Object: How Nash Equilibrium Illuminates Why Designs Stabilise, Plateau, and Change
- Prospect Theory works (Kahneman/Tversky)
- Nash Equilibrium in UX (Gopinath)
- The Inquiry Series, Ch 23 — Reference Points, Prospect Theory & the Mechanics of Satisfaction
Also known as
- ΔU model
- Deviation Utility
- Delta U
- ∆U model
- Deviation utility model
- Equilibrium switching model
- Nash Equilibrium deviation utility (∆U) model
Categories
- Community-Proposed Frameworks