Description
Assess the same person with and without contextual support to measure the range between everyday unaided performance and best supported performance on one scale.
Dynamic skill theory holds that competence is not a single level but a range. Functional level is what a person does with low support; optimal level is what they reach immediately after high support such as a model, rubric or prime; scaffolded performance with direct help sits higher still. The method plans this contrast as a design: the same task domain, the same person, assessed under graded support and scored on one common complexity scale (in the source, a 13-level scale validated with Rasch scaling). The optimal-functional gap usually exceeds one level, so any single assessment misstates capability. Its rigour comes from the common scale and the planned manipulation of support rather than an incidental comparison. For UX it reframes questions such as 'can users do this?' into 'what can they do alone, and what can they do with an example or guide beside them?'.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Unmigrated
- Stage
- Discovery, Evaluation
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Define the task domain and a complexity scoring scale that can be applied to all responses, ideally checked with Rasch or similar scaling.
- Assess each participant under low-support conditions to establish the functional level.
- Provide high support, such as a worked example, template or rubric, and reassess immediately to establish the optimal level.
- Optionally assess again with direct scaffolding from the researcher to obtain a scaffolded ceiling.
- Score all responses on the common scale and report the range per person; expect the optimal-functional gap to exceed one level.
- Record emotional state and context at each assessment, since both shift the level reached.
Sources
- Handbook of Child Psychology Vol 1 (Lerner et al., 2015)
Also known as
- Developmental range: functional versus optimal level assessment
- Optimal versus functional level
- Support manipulation assessment
- Dynamic skill assessment
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor