Description
Explicitly records design questions, alternative options, evaluation criteria and arguments, making the reasons behind design decisions inspectable and reusable.
Rittel created IBIS to structure deliberation on wicked problems: issues (questions), positions (responses) and arguments (pros and cons). MacLean and colleagues proposed QOC for design space analysis: questions identify key design issues, options are possible answers, and criteria are the bases for evaluating options, with assessments linking options to criteria. Recording rationale makes alternatives and trade-offs explicit, supports new team members, and prevents re-litigating decisions. It lost favour because capturing rationale felt costly, yet modern teams repeatedly lose the reasoning behind design choices. Lightweight QOC or IBIS maps (e.g. in decision records) restore it, and research findings can be linked directly as criteria evidence.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Participatory, Design & Futures
- Loss type
- Extinct
- Stage
- Design, Definition
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Identify key design questions during design reviews or research synthesis.
- Record options for each question, including rejected ones.
- State criteria explicitly, ideally linked to user research and business goals.
- Assess each option against criteria (positive or negative links) with evidence references.
- Record the decision and its justification, and link to related questions.
- Maintain the rationale map in a shared repository and revisit when criteria or evidence change.
Sources
- MacLean, Young, Bellotti & Moran, Questions, options, and criteria: Elements of design space analysis (1991), Human-Computer Interaction
- Kunz & Rittel, Issues as Elements of Information Systems (1970), Working Paper 131, UC Berkeley
- Conklin, Dialogue Mapping: Building Shared Understanding of Wicked Problems (2005)
Also known as
- Questions, Options and Criteria
- QOC
- Issue-Based Information System
- IBIS
- Design space analysis
- Dialogue mapping
Categories
- Design
- Participatory, Design & Futures