DeLone and McLean IS Success Model Measurement

Description

Judge a system's success with measures of information, system and service quality, use, user satisfaction and net benefits, and test how these dimensions relate rather than reporting one figure.

DeLone and McLean treat information systems success as several interdependent dimensions rather than a single variable. In the 2003 update, information quality, system quality and service quality each influence intention to use or actual use and user satisfaction; these influence each other and produce net benefits, which feed back into further use and satisfaction. Rigorous use starts by fixing the context, the stakeholder whose benefits count and the level of analysis, then selects a small set of validated measures for each dimension, combines them in one instrument and tests or controls the links among them. Use is judged by its nature, extent and appropriateness, not just time on system, and intention to use can stand in where use is mandatory. Reviews of validation studies found most of the hypothesised links supported, and the authors map each dimension to e-commerce metrics.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. Define the study's objectives, the system and context, the stakeholder whose benefits are judged and the level of analysis (individual, group or organisation).
  2. Choose a small number of validated measures for each of the six dimensions: information quality, system quality, service quality, intention to use or use, user satisfaction and net benefits.
  3. Combine the measures into a single instrument, pairing survey items with logged usage data where possible, since self-reported and recorded use can disagree.
  4. Treat management actions and organisational factors as independent variables, not as measures of success.
  5. Hypothesise the direction of links among the dimensions for this context before collecting data.
  6. Collect data and test the links with regression or structural equation modelling, or control for dimensions not under study.
  7. Interpret net benefits for the chosen stakeholder and feed them into decisions about further investment.

Sources

  • The DeLone and McLean Model of Information Systems Success: A Ten-Year Update (DeLone & McLean, 2003)

Also known as

  • D&M IS Success Model
  • Updated D&M IS Success Model
  • IS success measurement
  • Information systems success model

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Product Analytics & Strategy