Decoy effect measurement

Description

Measures how adding an inferior, asymmetrically dominated option shifts choice share towards the option it makes look better.

The decoy or attraction effect violates the regularity principle of rational choice: adding an option should never increase the share of an existing one, yet adding a decoy that is clearly worse than target A but not clearly worse than competitor B raises A's share. Decoy effect measurement quantifies this in a product's real option sets, typically pricing tiers, plans or bundles, by comparing choice shares between a core set and the same set plus a candidate decoy. Effects in laboratory studies are often 5 to 15 percentage points but are fragile: they shrink when attributes are not numerically comparable or when options are presented pictorially. Rigour therefore requires between-subjects randomisation, attribute-level dominance checks, and testing in the real presentation format rather than abstract tables.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Map the option set on its two or three decisive attributes (for example price and coverage) and identify the target option you want to make more attractive and its main competitor.
  2. Design a decoy that is dominated by the target on all decisive attributes but not by the competitor, typically 10% to 25% worse than the target on one attribute at a similar price.
  3. Randomise users between the core set and the core-plus-decoy set in the real interface; plan for several hundred choices per arm, since effects of 5 to 10 points need roughly 400 to 1,500 per arm for 80% power.
  4. Measure the target's share among choices of target and competitor, the decoy's own share (which should be small, under about 5%), and downstream outcomes such as refunds or churn.
  5. Test for regularity violation with a two-proportion test or logistic regression and report the effect size with a confidence interval.
  6. Assess ethics and robustness: confirm the target genuinely suits most choosers, and replicate on a second segment or format before rollout.

Sources

  • Paradox of Choice (Schwartz)
  • Think Bigger (Iyengar)
  • Happiness by Design (Dolan)
  • Methods Atlas (Gopinath)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 22 — Choice Architecture, Default Effects & Option Set Design

Also known as

  • Asymmetric dominance test
  • Attraction effect test
  • Decoy pricing test

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Behavioral Science & Economics