Decision-Centered Design with Decision Requirements Tables

Description

Centre design on a job's critical, difficult judgements: elicit them by cognitive task analysis, tabulate cues and strategies in decision requirements tables, storyboard concepts and evaluate with decision-stressing scenarios.

Decision-Centered Design is an end-to-end design process built on cognitive task analysis, whereas CTA alone stops at elicitation. It assumes that a system's value lies in supporting the few critical, difficult decisions and judgements a role involves. After domain familiarisation, experts are interviewed with the Knowledge Audit and Critical Decision Method and observed at work. Findings are compiled into decision requirements tables that list, for each key decision, why it is difficult, the cues and information used, common errors, and the strategies experts apply. These tables are transformed into design concepts and storyboards, and evaluated with scenarios built specifically to stress those decisions, against real-world outcome criteria rather than generic usability. The process has been applied to air campaign plan evaluation and a Navy landing signal officer display.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Months

Steps

  1. Prepare: familiarise yourself with the domain, roles and documentation.
  2. Elicit with cognitive task analysis: Knowledge Audit, Critical Decision Method interviews and observation of experts.
  3. Build decision requirements tables listing each critical decision, why it is difficult, cues and information used, typical errors and expert strategies.
  4. Transform the requirements into design concepts and storyboards that support each decision.
  5. Build evaluation scenarios that deliberately stress those decisions and test the concepts with practitioners.
  6. Set real-world outcome criteria and iterate design and evaluation.

Sources

  • Handbook of Cognitive Task Design (Hollnagel, 2003)

Also known as

  • Decision-Centered Design
  • DCD
  • Decision requirements table

Categories

  • User Research
  • Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling