Deceptive Pattern Analysis

Description

Identifies and classifies interface designs that steer users against their interests, using established taxonomies, to support ethical review and regulatory compliance.

Deceptive patterns are interface designs that trick or pressure users into actions they would not otherwise take, such as roach-motel cancellation, confirmshaming, hidden costs, sneak-into-basket and disguised ads. Harry Brignull coined the term and catalogue; academic work by Gray and colleagues and by Mathur and colleagues produced more rigorous taxonomies and showed prevalence at scale through automated crawls. As a method, an auditor walks key journeys, especially sign-up, purchase, consent and cancellation, captures each screen and codes instances against a taxonomy. Rigour comes from using a published taxonomy with definitions, having two coders independently classify instances, counting steps and asymmetries (for example clicks to subscribe versus to cancel), and mapping findings to regulations such as the EU Digital Services Act, GDPR consent rules and FTC guidance.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Select journeys most prone to deception: sign-up, checkout, consent, upgrade and cancellation.
  2. Walk each journey and capture every screen and step, including on mobile and web.
  3. Code instances against a published taxonomy (e.g. Gray et al. or Mathur et al.), with two coders working independently.
  4. Measure asymmetries such as steps to opt in versus opt out and default states of consent toggles.
  5. Rate each instance by harm and regulatory exposure, referencing applicable law.
  6. Recommend fair alternatives and re-audit after changes.

Sources

  • Designing for Behavior Change
  • Deceptive Patterns (Harry Brignull)

Related talks

Also known as

  • Dark pattern analysis
  • Dark patterns audit
  • Manipulative design audit

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation