Data structure diagram construction

Description

Builds a left-to-right diagram showing how informant-level concepts aggregate into themes and theoretical dimensions, making qualitative analysis traceable at a glance.

The data structure diagram is the visual centrepiece of Gioia-style analysis. First-order concepts are listed on the left, second-order themes in the middle and aggregate dimensions on the right, with lines or brackets showing which concepts form which themes. It is accompanied by a table of representative quotes. Its value is evidentiary: a reader can see the full chain from informants' words to theory, judge whether groupings are plausible, and see how much data underlies each theme. It is not a causal model; relationships among dimensions belong in the separate grounded theoretical model. Rigour comes from including every retained concept, ensuring each theme has several supporting concepts, and having the structure challenged by a second researcher.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Definition
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Finalise first-order concepts, phrased close to informant language, and remove duplicates or concepts supported by only one informant unless theoretically important.
  2. Confirm each second-order theme has at least 2 to 3 first-order concepts and each aggregate dimension has at least 2 themes.
  3. Lay out three columns (concepts, themes, dimensions) and connect them with brackets or arrows, ordering items so related ones sit together.
  4. Build an accompanying table with 2 to 4 representative quotes per first-order concept, each tagged with an informant identifier.
  5. Ask a colleague to test the diagram by trying to reassign concepts; groupings that are frequently contested should be revisited in the data.
  6. Present the diagram with the quote table in reports, and keep a separate model figure for relationships among dimensions.

Sources

  • Gioia (Administrative Science Quarterly) via Sage Handbook
  • Rocking Qualitative Social Science
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 28 — The Gioia Methodology — Identity-First Systematic Analysis

Also known as

  • Gioia data structure
  • Data structure figure
  • Concept-theme-dimension diagram

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis