Description
Models how experts fit data into frames, then elaborate, question, preserve or replace those frames, to design tools that support reframing when anomalies appear.
Klein's data-frame theory describes sensemaking as a reciprocal process: people use frames (stories, scripts, mental models) to decide which data matter, and data in turn confirm, elaborate or challenge frames. Key activities include elaborating a frame, questioning it when anomalies appear, preserving it by explaining anomalies away, comparing alternatives and reframing. Fixation, failing to reframe despite contrary evidence, is a major source of expert error. As a research method, analysts use cognitive task analysis interviews, often the Critical Decision Method, to reconstruct incidents and code when frames formed, which data triggered questioning and how long reframing took. Rigour comes from grounding analysis in real incidents, coding sensemaking functions explicitly, and designing tools that surface anomalies and alternative frames rather than reinforcing the first interpretation.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Select challenging incidents where experts had to interpret ambiguous or changing data.
- Conduct Critical Decision Method interviews with 6-12 experts, sweeping each incident multiple times for detail.
- Code each incident for frame formation, elaboration, questioning, preservation and reframing events.
- Identify anomalies that should have triggered reframing and the cues that were missed or explained away.
- Derive requirements for surfacing anomalies, showing alternative hypotheses and tracking frame confidence.
- Test prototypes in scenario-based evaluations that include frame-breaking events.
Sources
- Mapping Experiences
- Making Sense of Sensemaking 2: A Macrocognitive Model (Klein, Moon & Hoffman)
- Sources of Power (Gary Klein)
Also known as
- Data-Frame Theory
- Data/Frame model of sensemaking
Categories
- User Research
- Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling