Cynefin Sense-Making Framework

Description

Classifies situations as clear, complicated, complex, chaotic or confused, each calling for different research and decision approaches.

Cynefin distinguishes ordered domains, where cause and effect are knowable (clear: sense-categorise-respond; complicated: sense-analyse-respond, needing expertise), from unordered domains (complex: probe-sense-respond via safe-to-fail experiments; chaotic: act-sense-respond). A central zone of confusion (aporetic) covers not knowing which applies. Properly used, Cynefin is constructed by groups through contextualisation exercises, placing their own situations onto the framework from narrative data, rather than assigning domains top-down. For UX, it guides methodological choice: complicated problems call for expert analysis and rigorous evaluation, complex ones for portfolios of small probes and narrative sensing (e.g. SenseMaker).

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Stage
Strategy
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Collect situations or decisions as short narratives from teams or users.
  2. Run a contextualisation workshop: place items relative to each other, then draw domain boundaries emergently.
  3. For each domain, agree appropriate approaches: best practice, expert analysis, safe-to-fail probes or rapid action.
  4. For complex items, design a portfolio of parallel probes with amplification and dampening criteria.
  5. Monitor through narrative sensing and indicators, and re-assess domain placement over time.
  6. Watch for complacency moving clear items toward chaos.

Sources

  • Kurtz & Snowden, The new dynamics of strategy: Sense-making in a complex and complicated world (2003), IBM Systems Journal
  • Snowden & Boone, A leader's framework for decision making (2007), Harvard Business Review
  • Snowden et al., Cynefin: Weaving Sense-Making into the Fabric of Our World (2020)

Related talks

Also known as

  • Cynefin
  • Cynefin domains
  • Snowden's Cynefin

Categories

  • Strategy & Collaboration
  • Systems & Complexity