Cycle-by-Cycle Reconstruction of an Emergent Division of Labour

Description

From recordings, reconstruct each repetition of a team computation, the order of steps and who did each, then segment the series to show how a division of labour emerged.

A micro-analytic procedure for watching a team reorganise itself. After a ship's gyrocompass failed, two navigation team members corrected 66 lines of position with no procedure for sharing the work. Hutchins reconstructed each repetition by fitting known values to the numbers spoken on tape, notating calculator groupings and spoken intermediate sums, and coding who began, structured and completed each computation. Thirteen computational structures appeared before a stable one emerged, and the series fell into four regions, from data-driven improvisation to a stable division with a coined term for the shared step. The analysis shows that change came through local adaptation and local design, not a global designer, and that the final configuration may not be represented in any one person's head. It extends Distributed Cognition Analysis from describing a system to tracing how it learned.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Identify a computation or task cycle that a team repeats many times, ideally after a disruption.
  2. Record the values and resources available in the setting (reports, constants, tools) alongside audio and video.
  3. For each repetition, fit the available values to what was said or entered to recover the order of operations.
  4. Notate groupings and intermediate results, and code who began, structured and completed each repetition.
  5. Plot the sequence of configurations and partition it into regions by organising principle.
  6. Explain each transition as local adaptation, local design or global design, and identify the stable configuration.

Sources

  • Cognition in the Wild (Hutchins, 1995)

Also known as

  • Organisational learning microanalysis
  • Line-of-position reconstruction
  • Computational and social configuration tracking

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis