Cross-Screen Consistency Construction by Layer Intersection

Description

Design a multi-device product by taking what all screens share at the structure, frame and presentation layers as the core, then adding screen-specific adaptations and checking consistency.

The practice splits Garrett's layers into a macro level (strategy and scope), which should match users' value expectations, and a micro level (structure, frame and presentation), which should match the user's mental model of the product. Where devices are used in similar scenarios, the team designs the intersection of all screens at the micro layers first, so the core task flow, labels and visual language are shared, and only then merges in the differences forced by screen size and input method. Consistency is checked in three senses: content (same main functions and wording for labels, feedback and help), behaviour (same task flows while respecting each platform's gesture and navigation conventions) and form (shared style, comparable layout, a small consistent palette and platform fonts). A design specification then records controls, gestures, wording and colours so separate teams stay aligned.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Stage
Design
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Describe each device's usage scenarios (on the move or settled) and input modes (mouse and keyboard, touch, voice or body movement).
  2. Agree the macro layers (strategy and scope) across devices, and list the user tasks that occur on several devices in similar scenarios.
  3. For those tasks, design the shared core first: the structure, frame and presentation elements that every screen will have.
  4. Add the differences each screen needs for its size and input method, keeping platform conventions for gestures and navigation.
  5. Review the result for consistency of content and wording, behaviour and task flow, and form (style, layout, colour and type) across devices.
  6. Codify controls, gestures, wording and colour schemes in a shared design specification and assign an owner to maintain it.

Sources

  • Research on User Experience Design Consistency of Internet Products Based on User Experience (Wang et al., 2020)

Also known as

  • Multi-screen consistent experience design
  • Micro mental-model consistency construction
  • Layer-intersection cross-device design

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice