Critical Facet Playtest

Description

A survey-based playtest that measures players' attitudes to one specific core mechanic, such as aiming, camera or steering, rather than the whole game.

A critical facet playtest isolates one core experience that the game depends on and quantifies how players perceive it. Medlock gives examples such as the aiming model on vertical levels, the camera in a 3D platformer, or steering through turns in a racing game. Players play a slice of the game that exercises the facet, then answer rating questions focused only on it, so the team learns whether the mechanic feels right and can compare alternative tunings or later builds. Because the facet is narrow, the build can be early and the questionnaire short, and results can feed directly into tuning. The method shares the limits of other self-report playtests: it does not say why players felt the way they did, and it does not show whether the facet matters to overall enjoyment, so it is often paired with observation, interviews or telemetry. For UX research outside games, the idea transfers to any product with one interaction that carries the experience, such as a drawing tool's brush feel or a camera app's focus behaviour.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify the core facet the experience depends on and the decisions the team must make about it.
  2. Build or select a short play slice that exercises the facet repeatedly.
  3. Write focused rating items (for example feel, control, precision, satisfaction) plus one or two open questions.
  4. Recruit target players and have them play the slice, optionally across two or more tunings in counterbalanced order.
  5. Collect ratings immediately after each slice.
  6. Compare ratings between tunings or against earlier builds and follow up on outliers with observation or interview.

Sources

  • Drachen, A., Mirza-Babaei, P. & Nacke, L. (eds), Games User Research (2018)

Also known as

  • Core experience playtest
  • Facet playtest

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation