Critical Analysis Walkthrough

Description

A researcher maps an app's purpose, business model and governance, then uses it step by step from sign-up to exit to expose the values and exclusions built into its design.

The walkthrough method treats an app as a cultural artefact. Like a heuristic evaluation it needs no participants, but its aim is critical rather than diagnostic: to understand how the interface guides users, what ideal user it assumes, whose needs it privileges, and what that means for access and inclusion. The researcher first maps the environment of expected use: vision (purpose and target audience), operating model (business strategy and revenue) and modes of governance (terms of service and rules). They then walk through every button, menu and screen as a typical user across registration, everyday use and leaving, recording UI arrangement, functions, branding and wording, and interpreting each feature against prior research and social norms. It is distinct from the cognitive walkthrough, which predicts learnability problems.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Map the environment of expected use: the app's stated vision and audience, its business and revenue model, and its governance (terms of service, community rules).
  2. Create an account and walk through registration and entry, noting every field, option and default.
  3. Walk through everyday use screen by screen, recording UI arrangement, functions, features, wording, branding and colours.
  4. Walk through suspension, deletion or leaving, noting obstacles and retention tactics.
  5. Record everything with notes, screenshots or screen recording.
  6. Analyse critically: which actions are encouraged, how users are constrained, what ideal user is assumed, and whose needs are privileged or excluded.
  7. Pair the findings with interviews or usability tests to add users' own perceptions.

Sources

  • UX Research Methods for Media and Communication Studies (Cirucci & Pruchniewska, 2022)

Also known as

  • Critical analysis walkthrough (app walkthrough method)
  • Walkthrough method
  • App walkthrough method
  • Light, Burgess and Duguay walkthrough

Categories

  • Content
  • Linguistics, Semiotics & Discourse