Crab Canon Walkthrough

Description

Walk a flow backwards from its end state, checking at each step that the user can undo it, can tell where they are, and would make sense of the screen arriving from the other direction.

A crab canon is a piece of music that works played forwards or backwards. Hofstadter uses it, and a dialogue written the same way, to show structures that hold up when reversed. Most walkthroughs only go forwards, along the path designers intended, so they miss what happens when people change their mind, press back, cancel half-way or arrive at a middle step from a link or notification. The crab canon walkthrough starts at the end of a flow and moves backwards one step at a time. At each step the reviewer asks four questions: can this step be undone, and does undoing it restore what was there before; can the user tell what the previous step was; does the screen make sense if you arrive here from the step after it; and what happens to data entered on later steps. The result is a list of one-way doors and broken return paths that forward testing seldom finds.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Choose a flow and write down its steps in forward order, including the end state.
  2. Start at the end state and move back one step at a time, using the product's own back, cancel and undo controls where they exist.
  3. At each step answer: can it be undone; does undo restore the previous state exactly; can the user tell where they came from; does the screen make sense when reached from the following step.
  4. Record what happens to data entered later in the flow when the user goes back.
  5. Mark one-way doors (steps that cannot be undone) and check each is intentional and clearly signalled before the user takes it.
  6. Repeat with entry points in the middle of the flow, such as deep links and notifications.

Sources

  • Hofstadter, D., Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid (1979)

Also known as

  • Reverse-flow walkthrough
  • Reversibility walkthrough

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation