Description
Rate each UX problem's importance and cost to fix, rank by their ratio, accumulate costs, and fix everything above the iteration's line of affordability.
A cost-importance table lists each UX problem or problem group with an importance rating (M for must fix, then 5, 3 or 1, adjusted up for frequency and learnability impact), a proposed design solution, the cost to fix in person-hours including redesign, and a priority ratio of importance divided by cost multiplied by 1000. Problems are sorted by ratio, cumulative cost is computed down the list, and a line of affordability is drawn where cumulative cost exceeds the resources available for the iteration. Problems above the line are fixed; those below are deferred or accepted. Must-fix items stay above the line regardless of ratio. Variants handle problem groups, ties, multiple candidate solutions, extra weight for safety-critical problems, and a rapid team bubble sort without numbers. Recording actual costs calibrates future estimates.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Usability & Evaluation
- Loss type
- Vestigial
- Goal
- Prioritise, Support a decision
- Stage
- Evaluation
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- List UX problems and group related ones that share a fix.
- Rate importance to fix as M, 5, 3 or 1, raising it for high frequency or learnability impact and weighting safety-critical problems more.
- Propose a design solution for each (not training or documentation).
- Estimate cost to fix in person-hours, including redesign effort.
- Compute priority ratio = importance / cost x 1000 (M stays M), sort and rank.
- Compute cumulative cost down the ranked list and draw the line of affordability at the iteration's resource limit.
- Resolve each problem: fix above the line, defer or accept below; record actual costs to calibrate later estimates.
Sources
- The UX Book (Hartson & Pyla, 2019)
Also known as
- Cost-importance analysis with priority ratio and line of affordability
- Cost-importance table
- Priority ratio
- Line of affordability
Categories
- User Research
- Usability & Evaluation