Cost-Importance Analysis

Description

Rate each UX problem's importance and cost to fix, rank by their ratio, accumulate costs, and fix everything above the iteration's line of affordability.

A cost-importance table lists each UX problem or problem group with an importance rating (M for must fix, then 5, 3 or 1, adjusted up for frequency and learnability impact), a proposed design solution, the cost to fix in person-hours including redesign, and a priority ratio of importance divided by cost multiplied by 1000. Problems are sorted by ratio, cumulative cost is computed down the list, and a line of affordability is drawn where cumulative cost exceeds the resources available for the iteration. Problems above the line are fixed; those below are deferred or accepted. Must-fix items stay above the line regardless of ratio. Variants handle problem groups, ties, multiple candidate solutions, extra weight for safety-critical problems, and a rapid team bubble sort without numbers. Recording actual costs calibrates future estimates.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Stage
Evaluation
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. List UX problems and group related ones that share a fix.
  2. Rate importance to fix as M, 5, 3 or 1, raising it for high frequency or learnability impact and weighting safety-critical problems more.
  3. Propose a design solution for each (not training or documentation).
  4. Estimate cost to fix in person-hours, including redesign effort.
  5. Compute priority ratio = importance / cost x 1000 (M stays M), sort and rank.
  6. Compute cumulative cost down the ranked list and draw the line of affordability at the iteration's resource limit.
  7. Resolve each problem: fix above the line, defer or accept below; record actual costs to calibrate later estimates.

Sources

  • The UX Book (Hartson & Pyla, 2019)

Also known as

  • Cost-importance analysis with priority ratio and line of affordability
  • Cost-importance table
  • Priority ratio
  • Line of affordability

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation