Convergent Mixed Methods Design

Description

Collect and analyse quantitative and qualitative data on parallel questions in one phase, then merge the results and deliberately follow up any divergence.

One of the three core mixed methods designs, renamed from 'concurrent triangulation' to stress the intent of integration rather than timing. Both strands address parallel concepts, usually in the same period and often with a qualitative sample nested in the larger quantitative one. Each dataset is analysed separately with its own procedures, then merged: side by side in a discussion, by transforming qualitative codes into variables, or in a joint display. Fit between results is judged as concordance, expansion, complementarity or discordance (Fetters, 2020), leading to meta-inferences. The rigour lies in two requirements often skipped: questions must be genuinely parallel so results can be compared, and divergence must be pursued by re-analysis, more data or questioning one database, not simply noted as a limitation. Unequal sample sizes are handled by equalising, weighting or justifying the difference.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Write parallel quantitative and qualitative questions about the same concepts.
  2. Collect both datasets in the same phase, deciding whether the qualitative sample is nested in, overlaps with or is separate from the quantitative one.
  3. Analyse each dataset separately with its own procedures.
  4. Merge the results side by side, through data transformation, or in a joint display organised by concept.
  5. Judge fit for each concept as concordance, expansion, complementarity or discordance.
  6. Follow up discordance by re-analysing, collecting more data or questioning the quality of one source.
  7. State meta-inferences and how each strand contributed.

Sources

  • The Sage Handbook of Mixed Methods Research Design (Poth, 2023)
  • Research Design (5th ed.) (Creswell & Creswell, 2018)
  • Machine Learning Algorithms in UX Design: Enhancing User Experience in Digital Products (Alimbayeva, 2024)
  • Utilizing Qualitative Methods to Conduct Mixed Methods Research (Holtrop, 2023)
  • Value Added by Mixed Methods Research: A Multiphase Mixed Methods Design (Haines, 2011)

Also known as

  • Convergent parallel design
  • Concurrent triangulation design
  • QUAN + QUAL design

Categories

  • Research Operations
  • Research Design & Rigor