Contingency and Cue-Competition Judgement Task

Description

Show pairings of a candidate cause and an outcome, ask how strongly one predicts the other, compare judgements with delta-P, and use blocking designs to test cue competition.

People judge whether a feature, alert or action predicts an outcome from the cases they see, and they weight those cases unevenly. In the basic task, the four cells of a 2x2 table (cause present or absent by outcome present or absent) are shown as a summary or one case at a time; judgements are compared with delta-P, the difference between the outcome rate with and without the cause, and regressed on cell frequencies. People weight the cause-and-outcome cell most and the neither cell least, which McKenzie argues can be sensible when events are rare. Cue-competition designs show that credit is shared: once A predicts the outcome, a later companion B gets little credit (forward blocking), and learning about A alone can retrospectively reduce B's credit (backward blocking). The inverse base-rate design shows attention shifting to distinctive cues of rarer categories.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Choose a candidate cause and outcome relevant to the product question, for example a warning badge and a failed transaction.
  2. Contingency version: present the four cell frequencies as a table or as a sequence of cases, varying each cell systematically across conditions.
  3. Ask for a rating of how strongly the cause predicts or causes the outcome, keeping predictive and causal wording distinct.
  4. Compute delta-P for each condition and regress judgements on cell frequencies to estimate each cell's weight.
  5. Cue-competition version: train cue A with the outcome, then A and B together, and compare ratings of B with a control group that saw only the compound (forward blocking); reverse the phases for backward blocking.
  6. Base-rate version: train two categories with a shared cue plus distinctive cues at unequal frequencies, then test with conflicting distinctive cues.

Sources

  • Handbook of Cognition (Lamberts & Goldstone, 2005)

Also known as

  • Covariation judgement task
  • 2x2 contingency judgement with cell-frequency analysis
  • Delta-P judgement task
  • Forward and backward blocking design
  • Relative validity design
  • Inverse base-rate (highlighting) design

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Behavioral Science & Economics