Contextual Sound Testing

Description

Test product sounds in real places, at a ladder of distances, inside bags and across social settings to see whether they are heard, ignored or intrusive.

Whether a sound is welcomed, ignored or intrusive depends on time, place, noise, ability, culture and season, so lab listening misleads. Case and Day set out a structured series of contexts. Testers ideally live with the product at home. Sounds are checked inside a purse, backpack or pocket (where high frequencies are lost), across a distance ladder from in hand to behind a solid door and in large open spaces, on public transport with a colleague in busy and quiet conditions, on flights, and against cultural norms of politeness in each market. Social contexts (alone, coworkers, crowd, friends and family, school) each come with questions about disruption, and inclusive design cards prompt situational, temporary and permanent limitations. The result is a list of contextual failures and the settings users will need.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Where possible, give testers the product to use daily at home.
  2. Test audibility inside a purse, backpack and pocket, noting loss of high frequencies.
  3. Test at a distance ladder: in hand, on a table, across the room, next room with door open, behind a hollow door, behind a solid door, and in a large open space; note disturbance to others.
  4. Test on public transport with a colleague, seated together and apart, in busy and quiet conditions, and on a flight if possible.
  5. Review cultural expectations of loudness, length and politeness for each target market.
  6. Check each social context (alone, coworkers, crowd, friends and family, school) and situational, temporary and permanent limitations with inclusive design prompts.
  7. Record failures and the user settings required (volume, alert style by sender, silent mode).

Sources

  • Designing with Sound (Case & Day, 2018)

Also known as

  • In-context audibility testing
  • Sound testing at distances and in enclosures
  • Social-context sound testing

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation