Contextual Inquiry with Work Artefact Analysis

Description

Contextual inquiry that systematically collects and analyses the notes, printouts, spreadsheets and workarounds people create, revealing tacit needs and shadow systems interviews miss.

Contextual inquiry pairs observation and interview in the user's own setting under a master-apprentice model. Artefact analysis extends it by treating the physical and digital things people create or use as data in their own right: sticky notes on monitors, annotated printouts, personal spreadsheets, cheat sheets, renamed folders and custom tools. Each artefact is photographed or collected, and analysed for its structure, the information it carries, who creates and uses it, and the breakdowns it compensates for. Workarounds often form a shadow information system that reveals what the official product fails to support. Holtzblatt and Beyer's artefact model formalises this analysis. In contemporary practice contextual inquiry survives in shortened forms, and the systematic artefact component is usually dropped.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. During field observation, collect all artifacts users have created or modified: post-it notes, custom spreadsheets, printed manuals with annotations, physical workarounds. Photograph and catalog. Analyze artifact content for:
  2. information the interface failed to surface (filled gaps),
  3. actions the interface failed to afford (physical workarounds),
  4. mental models embedded in artifact structure.

Sources

  • Universal Methods of Design — Bella Martin
  • Ethnographic Thinking (Hasbrouck)
  • Handbook of Ethnography
  • Rocking Qualitative Social Science
  • Contextual Design (Hugh Beyer & Karen Holtzblatt)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 31 — Ethnographic Fieldwork — Thick Description & Niche Construction

Also known as

  • Artefact analysis
  • Contextual inquiry with artifact collection
  • Work artefact model

Categories

  • User Research
  • Field & Ethnographic