Content model validation

Description

Tests whether a structured content model's types, attributes and relationships actually fit real content, user needs and publishing contexts before it is built.

A content model defines content types (article, product, procedure), their attributes and the relationships between them. Validation checks it in three ways: against real content (can a representative sample be decomposed into the model without forcing or loss?), against user tasks (do the types and relationships support the queries and journeys users need?), and against channels (can the content render appropriately in each output, from web to voice to device screens?). Rigorous validation borrows from data modelling: test with real instances, look for overloaded fields and free-text dumping grounds, and measure fit. In practice validation is often a stakeholder walkthrough of a diagram, which is why the method is vestigial.

Attributes

Loss type
Vestigial
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Gather a stratified sample of real content, at least 30-50 items across all candidate types and sources.
  2. Attempt to decompose each item into the model, recording forced fits, missing attributes, overloaded fields and unused attributes.
  3. Compute fit metrics: percentage of items modelled without loss (target at least 90%) and percentage of attributes used in at least 20% of items.
  4. Test task support by writing the queries and journeys users need and checking the model can answer them through its relationships.
  5. Prototype rendering for each target channel and check required fields exist for each.
  6. Revise the model and repeat with a fresh sample before implementation in the CMS.

Sources

  • Rosenfeld, L., Morville, P. & Arango, J., Information Architecture: For the Web and Beyond (O'Reilly, 4th ed., 2015)
  • Martin, L. M., Everyday Information Architecture (2019)
  • Covert, A., How to Make Sense of Any Mess (2014)
  • Information Architecture (O'Reilly)
  • Everyday Information Architecture (Martin)
  • How to Make Sense of Any Mess (Covert)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 7 — Graph Theory & the Architecture of Information

Also known as

  • Content model testing
  • Structured content model review

Categories

  • Content
  • Information Architecture & Content