Description
Check that a participant can understand, appreciate, reason about and communicate a choice, and adapt consent, involve a surrogate and respect assent or dissent rather than excluding them.
Capacity to consent has four elements: understanding the information, appreciating how it applies to oneself, reasoning about options, and communicating a consistent choice. Screening starts informally, through conversation before disclosure and a brief understanding check afterwards; when in doubt a formal tool is used, such as the MacCAT-CR semi-structured interview (15-30 minutes) or the 10-item UBACC. Thresholds are set by the study's risk, and capacity is reassessed because it fluctuates. Where capacity is insufficient, the person may still be able to designate a surrogate, assessed with open questions about whom they trust for important decisions; the surrogate must understand the research, its risks and the person's values. Assent is sought before and during participation and dissent from either party usually ends it. Autonomy is supported with simpler language, multimedia, more time and repeated consent.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Goal
- Assess risk and harm
- Stage
- Discovery, Evaluation
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Decide in the protocol whether people who may lack capacity are included and why their inclusion is necessary.
- Screen informally by conversation before disclosure and with a brief understanding check after it.
- Use a formal tool such as the MacCAT-CR or the 10-item UBACC when capacity is in doubt, with thresholds set by study risk.
- Adapt the process to support understanding: plain language, visuals, gradual presentation, a trusted companion, extra time, and timing at periods of lower impairment.
- If capacity remains insufficient, assess whether the person can designate a surrogate, document it, and check the surrogate understands the research and the person's values.
- Obtain surrogate permission and the person's assent; reassess capacity and assent during the study and treat dissent as a stop.
Sources
- Cambridge Handbook of Research Methods (Nichols & Edlund, 2023)
- Research Ethics Consultation (Danis et al., 2012)
Also known as
- Capacity-to-consent screening
- Capacity assessment
- MacCAT-CR
- UBACC
- Supported decision-making
- Research surrogate designation
- Assent and dissent procedures
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor