Description
A person delivers by hand, openly, the value a planned product would provide to a few real customers, testing demand and willingness to pay before building anything.
A concierge MVP replaces software with people and existing tools. The core value is stated as a hypothesis with a success criterion, then delivered manually to around five customers who know a person is doing the work (unlike Wizard of Oz, where the human is hidden). Each customer's first impression, problems, requests and complaints are logged, feedback is sought at meaningful moments with behaviour weighted over words, and obvious problems are fixed between rounds. Validation is willingness to pay: the service is announced as becoming paid at a committed, discounted price and agreements are recorded. Beyond demand, it reveals what people actually use, unexpected audiences and better ideas, and refines the service process before code is written. Airbnb's hand-taken listing photos, which gave two to three times more bookings, are the canonical case.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Experimentation & Causal Inference
- Loss type
- Active
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- State the product's core value as a hypothesis with a measurable success criterion, decided before starting.
- Design a manual way to deliver that value using human expertise and existing tools (email, SMS, phone, spreadsheets).
- Write and test a short pitch; recruit about five customers where the audience gathers and set expectations about the service.
- Deliver the service exactly as promised and log key events per customer: first impression, first problem, requests, complaints.
- Ask for feedback at meaningful moments, weighting behaviour over stated opinion, and fix clear problems between rounds.
- Announce that the service will become paid at a committed, discounted price and record who agrees; compare results with a baseline or market average.
- Repeat rounds, then build a prototype if validated (choosing a key metric that reflects the proven link) or pivot the idea or audience.
Sources
- Validating Product Ideas (Sharon, 2016)
- Lean Analytics (Croll & Yoskovitz, 2013)
- Product Management for UX People (Crumlish, 2022)
- UX Strategy (Levy, 2015)
Also known as
- Concierge test
- Concierge minimum viable product
- Manual-first MVP
Categories
- Analytics & Behaviour
- Experimentation & Causal Inference