Conceptually ordered display

Description

Arranges qualitative data by concepts or variables rather than by case or time, revealing how themes cluster, relate and vary across participants.

Among Miles and Huberman's display families, conceptually ordered displays organise data around concepts. A conceptually clustered matrix places research questions or themes that belong together as columns, with participants or cases as rows, so the analyst can see how answers to related questions co-vary. Other forms include thematic conceptual matrices, folk taxonomies (hierarchies of how participants classify things) and cognitive maps. The approach helps move from codes to an understanding of how concepts hang together and which participants share configurations. Rigour comes from grouping columns on conceptual grounds stated in advance or derived explicitly from the data, from consistent cell entries (short quotes or ratings with sources), and from verification tactics such as clustering, counting and checking outliers.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Definition
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify a set of related concepts or research questions that should be examined together, for example motives, barriers and workarounds for digital entry.
  2. Group concepts into clusters with stated rationale, and set them as matrix columns; set participants or cases as rows.
  3. Fill each cell with a short summary, rating or quote with identifier, using a written entry rule to ensure consistency.
  4. Sort rows to bring similar profiles together, and look for clusters of participants with similar configurations across columns.
  5. Where participants use their own classifications, build a folk taxonomy showing their categories and subcategories.
  6. Write analytic text describing clusters, relationships among concepts and outliers, and test conclusions by re-sorting the matrix on different columns.

Sources

  • Qualitative Data Analysis (Miles & Huberman) via Sage Handbook
  • Cambridge Handbook of Research Methods
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 29 — Miles & Huberman — Systematic Qualitative Data Analysis
  • Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)

Also known as

  • Conceptually clustered matrix
  • Conceptually ordered matrix
  • Taxonomy display

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis