Component and Analogous Prototyping for Physical Products

Description

Prototype each part of an electronic product separately or with a cheaper analogous part, then combine them in a series of prototypes each testing one assumption in context.

Smart objects and wearables fail in many places at once, so this practice breaks prototyping into controllable pieces. Before buying parts the designer writes the user flow, an if-this-then-that story of inputs and outputs and pseudocode, and draws a circuit diagram checked by someone who reads circuits. Each component (sensor, output, control) is prototyped and debugged alone before being combined, so troubleshooting is limited to the joins. Where real parts are large or costly, an analogous prototype tests the interaction first: a small dial and one LED for a wall-sized installation, or a screen mock of an LED array. Each subsequent prototype has one goal, such as whether haptic pulses are acceptable on the arm, pacing rates in daily wear, user control, materials for sport or long-term use, and is tested where and how the product will be used. Spare copies are built because fragile wiring breaks mid-session.

Attributes

Loss type
Active
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Write the user flow and an if-this-then-that story of inputs and outputs, and turn it into pseudocode.
  2. Draw a circuit diagram and have someone with electronics knowledge check it before buying parts.
  3. Prototype each component (sensor, output, control) separately until it works reliably.
  4. Where components are costly or large, test the interaction with an analogous cheaper part or a screen mock.
  5. Combine components and debug only the transitions between them.
  6. Give each further prototype one goal (acceptability, settings, control, materials, long-term use) and test it with users in the real environment and body position.
  7. Build spare copies and reinforce joints before user sessions.
  8. Carry findings into the next prototype until a full-function prototype is reached.

Sources

  • Prototyping for Designers (McElroy, 2016)

Also known as

  • Component prototypes
  • Analogous prototype
  • Staged physical prototype series

Categories

  • Design
  • Design & Product Practice