Communicative Temptation Task

Description

Stage a situation that tempts a participant to communicate, such as a desirable item they cannot reach, and observe how they signal requests or refusals.

This is structured observation: the situation is arranged so that the behaviour of interest becomes likely, in contrast to low-structured observation of natural play. In the request version an attractive toy is sealed in a transparent container the child cannot open. A child not yet communicating intentionally bangs and fusses; a preverbal communicator hands it to the adult, makes eye contact, points or vocalises, and persists. Rejection is elicited by offering a less-desirable item while preferred ones are visible but out of reach. Coding adult-directed behaviours (giving, eye contact, pointing, vocalising, persistence) reveals whether and how a participant communicates intent before or without speech. It is used in research and in clinical evaluation, and suits product research with users who cannot be interviewed.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Decide which communicative act to elicit: request, rejection or both.
  2. Set up the temptation: a desirable item in a container the participant cannot open, or an unwanted item offered while preferred ones are visible but out of reach.
  3. Brief the adult partner to wait and not anticipate the participant's needs.
  4. Observe live or record on video from an angle that captures gaze and gestures.
  5. Code adult-directed behaviours: giving, eye contact, pointing, vocalising and persistence, with two coders for reliability.
  6. Summarise the forms of intentional communication observed for each participant.

Sources

  • The Development of Language (Gleason & Ratner, 2024)

Also known as

  • Communicative temptations
  • Structured elicitation of requests and rejections

Categories

  • User Research
  • Field & Ethnographic