Collaborative Vignette

Description

A short, chronological story of a representative episode, written by or with a participant to a fixed outline, used to understand and communicate how something typically unfolds.

A vignette is a focused description of a series of events taken to be representative, typical or emblematic in the case. It has a narrative storyline that keeps chronological flow and is limited to a brief time span, one or a few actors, or a bounded space. In the collaborative form the researcher agrees an outline with participants (the context, your hopes, who was involved, what you did, what happened as a result, what the impact was, why this happened, other comments), and each participant chooses a situation and writes or dictates an uncritical account. The researcher annotates it with queries, the participant revises, and a final pseudonymised version can be circulated. Researchers can also write vignettes alone from processed field notes, or compose 'narrative scenes' near the end of a study. The book warns that vignettes are vivid and persuasive and can mislead: ask whether each is really typical, use several, and watch for self-serving 'success' stories. In UX, vignettes give rich, participant-authored accounts of episodes such as a failed onboarding or a team adopting a tool, and they communicate findings better than quotes alone.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Stage
Discovery
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify a 'pocket' of meaningful activity worth describing (a typical support escalation, a first week of use).
  2. Agree a short outline of headings with participants: context, hopes, who was involved, what you did, what happened, impact, why.
  3. Ask each participant to pick a real episode and write or dictate it against the outline, without worrying about style.
  4. Read it, add marginal questions, discuss them, and have the participant revise and expand.
  5. Replace names with pseudonyms and check the vignette against the wider data for typicality.
  6. Use several vignettes together, with commentary, rather than a single compelling story.

Sources

  • Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)

Also known as

  • Vignette (Miles and Huberman)
  • Narrative scene
  • Day-in-the-life vignette
  • Analytic vignette

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis