Description
Turn a set of stakeholder or expert probabilities into linear programmes that show whether the set contradicts itself and what range any further probability must lie in.
When stakeholders give probabilities for related events (adoption, churn, a regulatory delay), the set can be internally contradictory without anyone noticing. De Finetti treated a probability as a price you would both pay and accept for a claim; a set is coherent if no combination of such trades guarantees a loss. The fundamental theorem of prevision turns this into linear programming over the joint outcomes allowed by the logical links between events. If no probability vector reproduces the stated values, the set is incoherent and the conflicting assertions can be shown. If it is feasible, minimising and maximising a new event's probability gives the coherent range it must lie in; the range is a single value only when the new event is a linear combination of the stated ones. Lad's example: two assessed probabilities of 0.1 and 0.75 force the probability that exactly one event occurs into 0.65 to 0.85.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Game Theory & Decision Science
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Strategy, Definition
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- List the events already assessed and the new event of interest.
- Enumerate the joint outcomes permitted by the logical relations between the events, keeping the set small because the list grows exponentially.
- Write each stated probability as a linear constraint on the outcome probabilities, with non-negativity and a sum of one; enter stated intervals as inequalities.
- Check feasibility; if infeasible, show the stakeholder the conflicting subset and ask them to revise.
- Minimise and maximise the new event's probability to obtain its coherent interval.
- If the interval is too wide to act on, elicit the new probability directly and recheck coherence.
Sources
- Operational Subjective Statistical Methods (Lad, 1996)
Also known as
- Fundamental theorem of prevision
- Coherence bounds
- Dutch book check
- Probability coherence linear programming
- De Finetti coherence check
Categories
- Strategy & Collaboration
- Game Theory & Decision Science