Cognitive Dimensions of Notations

Description

A vocabulary of about 14 dimensions, such as viscosity, hidden dependencies and premature commitment, for evaluating how well a notation or information artefact supports an activity.

The framework evaluates notations (programming languages, diagram editors, spreadsheets, design tools) not by surface usability but by how their structure supports different activities: incrementation, transcription, modification, exploratory design and searching. Dimensions include viscosity (resistance to change), visibility, premature commitment, hidden dependencies, role-expressiveness, error-proneness, abstraction gradient, secondary notation, progressive evaluation, provisionality, closeness of mapping, consistency, diffuseness and hard mental operations. Dimensions trade off against each other, and the profile needed depends on the activity. It gives designers and users a shared 'discussion tool' and is excellent for evaluating complex creation tools, including no-code builders and prompt interfaces.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify the notation and the main user activities (e.g. exploratory design versus modification).
  2. Define the desired profile: which dimensions matter most for those activities.
  3. Evaluate the notation against each dimension with concrete examples, or administer the Blackwell-Green CD questionnaire to experienced users.
  4. Record trade-offs, such as reducing viscosity at the cost of increased abstraction.
  5. Compare against the desired profile and prioritise design changes.
  6. Optionally run targeted tasks (e.g. modification tasks) to measure the most problematic dimensions.

Sources

  • Green & Petre, Usability analysis of visual programming environments: a 'cognitive dimensions' framework (1996), Journal of Visual Languages and Computing
  • Blackwell & Green, A Cognitive Dimensions questionnaire optimised for users (2000), PPIG

Also known as

  • CDs
  • Cognitive dimensions framework
  • Cognitive Dimensions questionnaire

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation