Claims Analysis

Description

Identifies the psychological claims, the upsides and downsides, that a design feature makes about users, and traces them to outcomes in usage scenarios.

Claims analysis is a design rationale technique from scenario-based design. For each key feature of a design, the analyst writes a claim describing the feature together with its hypothesised positive and negative psychological consequences for users, for example 'animated tutorial: + shows the task in context, - may be hard to follow at the user's own pace'. Claims are derived by walking through usage scenarios and asking questions grounded in Norman's stages of action. They make design trade-offs explicit, connect design decisions to psychological theory, and can be reused across projects as a body of design knowledge. Rigour comes from grounding claims in specific scenarios, stating both upsides and downsides, linking claims to evidence or theory, and testing important claims with users.

Attributes

Loss type
Extinct
Stage
Design
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Write usage scenarios that describe realistic user goals and activities with the design.
  2. Walk through each scenario, identifying the features that most affect user experience.
  3. For each feature, write a claim stating its hypothesised upsides and downsides for users.
  4. Ground each claim in theory or evidence, such as Norman's stages of action or prior studies.
  5. Review claims as a team to identify trade-offs and design alternatives.
  6. Test the most consequential claims in usability sessions and update the claims library.

Sources

  • Human-Computer Interaction
  • Lost Methods in UX
  • Usability Engineering: Scenario-Based Development (Rosson & Carroll)
  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Carroll JM & Rosson MB (1992) Getting around the task-artifact cycle. ACM TOIS 10(2)
  • Carroll JM (Ed) (1995) Scenario-Based Design
  • Rosson MB & Carroll JM (2002) Usability Engineering: Scenario-Based Development of HCI

Also known as

  • Psychological claims analysis
  • Scenario-based claims analysis
  • Design rationale claims
  • Claims-based design rationale

Categories

  • User Research
  • Task Analysis & Cognitive Modelling