Description
Induces realistic performance pressure and compares performance under a skill-focused secondary task with an unrelated dual task, to find out whether a skill is automated and how pressure breaks it.
Laboratory choking studies build pressure from several sources at once: a monetary incentive, peer pressure (a partner's reward depends on you, and the partner has supposedly already succeeded) and social evaluation (being filmed for experts to review). Manipulation checks confirm that pressure was felt, using state anxiety, rated importance and reported thoughts. To find the mechanism, the paradigm compares two secondary tasks. In the skill-focused condition the person attends to a part of their own execution (for example, which side of the foot last touched the ball). In the dual-task condition they monitor something unrelated, such as tones. Experts are harmed by skill focus but not by the distraction, while novices show the opposite, because expert skill runs as proceduralised units that break down when attended to. Under pressure, experts shift attention inward. For UX this matters in two ways. It tests whether expert users' fast interactions (keyboard shortcuts, game controls, clinical order entry) are automated and fragile under pressure. It also warns that asking experts to narrate step by step during testing can itself degrade their performance.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Experimentation & Causal Inference
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Evaluation
- Data
- Quantitative
- Effort
- Weeks
Steps
- Choose a well-practised interaction and recruit novices and experienced users.
- Establish baseline performance under low pressure.
- Run a skill-focused condition (attend to a component of one's own actions) and an unrelated dual-task condition, counterbalanced.
- Introduce a combined pressure manipulation (incentive, partner dependence, being recorded for review) for a randomised group.
- Check the manipulation with anxiety, importance and thought reports.
- Compare performance by expertise, attention condition and pressure, and inspect fine-grained timing or error data.
- Use findings to shape interfaces and training for high-stakes moments, and to choose think-aloud or silent protocols for expert testing.
Sources
- Tenenbaum, G. & Eklund, R. (eds), Handbook of Sport Psychology, 3rd ed. (2007)
Also known as
- Pressure induction paradigm
- Skill-focused versus dual-task attention paradigm
- Explicit monitoring test
- Laboratory choking manipulation
Categories
- Analytics & Behaviour
- Experimentation & Causal Inference