Description
Two short checklists that make researchers question their own values before a study with children, and plan how children can give genuinely informed consent.
CHECk is an ethics tool for design and evaluation work with children. Its premise is that ethics is more than a signed consent form: in a school, teachers consent on behalf of a class, and a child may find it hard to refuse. CHECk1 asks six questions before any activity, pushing the team to be honest about why they are building the technology, why children are involved, and what values drive the work. CHECk2 looks before and beyond the activity from the child's side: what the children will be told about the activity, how their contributions will be used and disseminated, and who will get credit for their ideas. The aim is 'ethical symmetry', where children consent in their own right rather than adults consenting for them. Completing the checklists also surfaces weaknesses in study design and forces the team to work out how to explain the study in words children understand. The chapter also varied how much ethical information children received, showing that the briefing itself can be studied. For UX teams working with minors or other groups with unequal power, CHECk is a practical way to move beyond compliance.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Research Design & Rigor
- Loss type
- Siloed
- Goal
- Assess risk and harm
- Data
- Qualitative
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Before planning sessions, have the team answer the six CHECk1 questions in writing about the purpose of the technology and of involving children.
- Revisit the study design in light of the answers, dropping or changing activities that cannot be justified.
- Work through CHECk2: decide what children will be told, how their data and ideas will be used and credited, and how this will be explained.
- Write a child-friendly script for the briefing and for asking assent, and make it easy for a child to decline.
- Run the study, giving every child the same briefing, and debrief afterwards on how their contribution will be used.
- Keep the completed checklists with the study records and review them after the study.
Sources
- Garcia-Ruiz, M. (ed.), Games User Research: A Case Study Approach (2016)
Also known as
- CHECk tool
- CHECk1 and CHECk2
- Child Ethics Checklists
Categories
- Research Operations
- Research Design & Rigor