Causal Chain and Antecedents Matrix

Description

Linear chains of what leads to what, and a matrix ordered by an outcome showing which antecedent variables act as immediate or remote causes in each case.

Early in causal modelling it helps to make simplifying assumptions and lay causes and effects out as a linear chain, for example individualisation, then pupil self-pacing, then inability to monitor, then development of trust, then 'letting go', then a changed self-image. Chains are quick to communicate and can also explain decline (initial difficulties, annoyance, resignation, guilt, futility), though they must later be elaborated into networks. In cross-case causal networking, the analyst isolates for each case the stream of variables leading to an outcome and compares streams across cases. The antecedents matrix gives the big picture without getting lost in stream-by-stream matching: it is ordered by the outcome variable and shows all variables that seem to be at work in producing it, clustered conceptually. Each cell records whether the variable is an immediate cause (no more than two steps from the outcome) or a remote cause, with its strength (high, moderate, low), or is left blank. Reading column by column yields statements such as 'user commitment is a remote cause in high-impact cases and absent in low ones'. Families of cases sharing a scenario are then sought and verified. For UX it turns many interview-based explanations into a structured comparison of what drives an outcome like retention.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Write simple causal chains for key processes in each case, from the field notes.
  2. For each case, trace the stream of variables leading to the outcome and mark immediate (within two steps) and remote causes.
  3. List variables that appear in at least a third of the case streams, plus conceptually important ones, clustered under headings.
  4. Build a matrix with cases ordered by outcome as rows and these variables as columns; enter cause type and strength.
  5. Read each column and write a summary statement of its role across cases.
  6. Group cases with similar streams into families and check them against the original networks.

Sources

  • Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)

Also known as

  • Causal chain
  • Antecedents matrix
  • Cross-case causal stream analysis

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis