Case-Oriented Mixed Analysis (Data Consolidation into Case Profiles)

Description

Link qualitative and quantitative data at the level of each case into mixed profiles, then compare profiles and re-read exceptional cases to explain under what conditions outcomes differ.

Most mixed analysis integrates only at the level of group findings. Case-oriented analysis integrates at the level of the individual case. Each strand is analysed first (codes, counts, scale scores, interaction codes), then elements are tagged by strand and consolidated into one profile per case mixing text, numbers and visuals; profiles become a new dataset to compare within and across groups. Vogl consolidated qualitative, count and Bales interaction strands from five children's focus groups into role profiles per child. Bustamante's variant starts after a group-level merge: compute each participant's change on several measures, select as exceptional those above the group mean on several scales, look for shared characteristics, and re-read their qualitative data against the group, displaying continua from negative to exceptional experiences. Thresholds are a judgement call, case numbers are small, and transforming qualitative data into numbers can mislead without coder checks.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Analyse each strand separately (for example interview codes, survey scale scores, behavioural counts).
  2. Link data by case and tag every element by its source strand.
  3. Consolidate into one mixed profile per case.
  4. Compare profiles within and across groups to find patterns and types.
  5. For outcome studies, compute each case's change per measure and flag cases above the group mean change on several measures as exceptional.
  6. Compare exceptional cases' characteristics and re-read their qualitative data against the rest of the group.
  7. Display results as continua or profile matrices and draw meta-inferences about conditions for success.

Sources

  • The Sage Handbook of Mixed Methods Research Design (Poth, 2023)

Also known as

  • Data consolidation
  • Case profiles
  • Case-oriented merged analysis
  • Exceptional case analysis in convergent designs

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis