Case Dynamics Matrix

Description

A matrix that lists the pressures or demands a change creates and traces, for each, the underlying issue, how people coped and how things finally settled.

The case dynamics matrix gives a preliminary explanation of 'what leads to what'. Rows are forces for change, things with a pushing or demanding quality, such as the demands, requirements or strains an innovation imposes. Columns trace each one through the underlying issue or assumption about what the demand means, the coping responses of the organisation or people, and the resulting changes, for example sorted into structural, procedural and climate effects. Data are pulled from coded chunks on implementation problems, effects on practice and climate, and informants' own explanations. Decision rules include locating clearly different demands, summarising each demand, coping method and resolution in a phrase, and using only data not contradicted by other informants; the 'underlying issue' column asks the analyst to move up a level of abstraction. Much of the analysis happens during entry, and a summarising text is then written by cycling back to the notes. The display deliberately covers only demands that produced change. For UX, it shows how teams or users absorb the friction a product introduces: which pains are worked around, which reshape process, and which lead to abandonment.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. List the demands or strains the product or change places on people, one per row.
  2. For each, write the underlying issue it reflects, at a more abstract level.
  3. Record how people or teams coped with it.
  4. Record how it was resolved and what changed, sorted by type of effect.
  5. Use only data not contradicted by other informants, and note decision rules.
  6. Write a summary of the dynamics, then test it against the notes or move to a causal network.

Sources

  • Miles, M. & Huberman, A. M., Qualitative Data Analysis: An Expanded Sourcebook, 2nd ed. (1994)

Also known as

  • Forces-for-change matrix
  • Demands, coping and outcomes matrix

Categories

  • User Research
  • Qualitative Analysis & Synthesis