Description
Uses structured card sets representing values or value-related prompts to help users and stakeholders articulate, prioritise and trade off values relevant to a technology.
Values are hard to elicit directly; people struggle to articulate them and give socially desirable answers. Card-based methods give tangible prompts: Schwartz value cards (e.g. security, autonomy, benevolence) can be sorted and ranked; Envisioning Cards prompt consideration of stakeholders, time, values and pervasiveness. Combined with laddering or think-aloud during sorting, they surface value priorities, conflicts and trade-offs. Rigorous use draws cards from validated value theories, records sorting data for quantitative analysis (rank orders, Q-sort-like distributions) and couples sorting with qualitative explanation. It is especially relevant for AI, privacy and wellbeing design.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Interviewing & Elicitation
- Loss type
- Latent
- Goal
- Explore unknowns, Prioritise
- Data
- Mixed
- Effort
- Days
Steps
- Select a card set grounded in theory (Schwartz values, VSD values, Envisioning Cards) and adapt wording to context.
- Introduce the technology or scenario to participants.
- Ask participants to sort cards by importance, or into piles (most to least relevant), thinking aloud.
- Probe trade-offs: present pairs of values in tension within the scenario.
- Record rankings and explanations; analyse rank orders quantitatively and explanations qualitatively.
- Translate value priorities and conflicts into design requirements and evaluation criteria.
Sources
- Schwartz, Universals in the content and structure of values (1992), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology
- Friedman & Hendry, The Envisioning Cards: A toolkit for catalyzing humanistic and technical imaginations (2012), CHI
- Friedman & Hendry, Value Sensitive Design: Shaping Technology with Moral Imagination (2019)
Also known as
- Value cards
- Envisioning Cards
- Values-based card sorting
- Schwartz value cards
Categories
- User Research
- Interviewing & Elicitation