Card-Based Value Elicitation

Description

Uses structured card sets representing values or value-related prompts to help users and stakeholders articulate, prioritise and trade off values relevant to a technology.

Values are hard to elicit directly; people struggle to articulate them and give socially desirable answers. Card-based methods give tangible prompts: Schwartz value cards (e.g. security, autonomy, benevolence) can be sorted and ranked; Envisioning Cards prompt consideration of stakeholders, time, values and pervasiveness. Combined with laddering or think-aloud during sorting, they surface value priorities, conflicts and trade-offs. Rigorous use draws cards from validated value theories, records sorting data for quantitative analysis (rank orders, Q-sort-like distributions) and couples sorting with qualitative explanation. It is especially relevant for AI, privacy and wellbeing design.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Data
Mixed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Select a card set grounded in theory (Schwartz values, VSD values, Envisioning Cards) and adapt wording to context.
  2. Introduce the technology or scenario to participants.
  3. Ask participants to sort cards by importance, or into piles (most to least relevant), thinking aloud.
  4. Probe trade-offs: present pairs of values in tension within the scenario.
  5. Record rankings and explanations; analyse rank orders quantitatively and explanations qualitatively.
  6. Translate value priorities and conflicts into design requirements and evaluation criteria.

Sources

  • Schwartz, Universals in the content and structure of values (1992), Advances in Experimental Social Psychology
  • Friedman & Hendry, The Envisioning Cards: A toolkit for catalyzing humanistic and technical imaginations (2012), CHI
  • Friedman & Hendry, Value Sensitive Design: Shaping Technology with Moral Imagination (2019)

Also known as

  • Value cards
  • Envisioning Cards
  • Values-based card sorting
  • Schwartz value cards

Categories

  • User Research
  • Interviewing & Elicitation