Description
A 3 x 4 inspection grid crossing User, Environment and Information with Context, Alert style, Usage and Edge cases to find where a product demands too much attention.
Case's grid is an evaluative tool for walking through a product's states and alerts to find unnecessary intrusions. Three rows (User, Environment, Information) are crossed with four columns (Context, Alert style, Usage, Edge cases), giving twelve prompts that must all be filled, like a multiplication table. Examples include whether the attention an alert demands matches the importance of its information, what in the environment could mask or make an alert inappropriate, how each alert is acknowledged, which users would struggle, and what happens when information is wrong or missing, including whether the device falls back to an earlier analogue state. Environment has its own row because a connected device behaves within settings designers predict but do not control. It builds empathy and helps explain a product to managers and developers.
Attributes
- Discipline
- Usability & Evaluation
- Loss type
- Latent
- Stage
- Design, Evaluation
- Data
- Analytical / expert
- Effort
- Hours
Steps
- Draw the 3 x 4 grid on paper, a whiteboard or a wall of sticky notes.
- User row: record who uses the device and their limits, how alerts take focus, setup and dismissal of each alert, and which people would struggle.
- Environment row: record where it lives, what could mask an alert or make it inappropriate, environmental limits on action (gloves, public places) and unusual situations.
- Information row: record what users must know, whether alert intensity matches importance, other available channels, what users do with the information, and behaviour when it is wrong or absent.
- Fill every cell, iterating rather than expecting to get it right first time.
- Use the gaps to redesign alerts and fallbacks, and sketch the revised device with callouts for key interaction points.
Sources
- Calm Technology (Case, 2015)
Also known as
- Calm interaction evaluation tool
- Calm Design evaluation grid
Categories
- User Research
- Usability & Evaluation