C-HIP Warning Effectiveness Analysis

Description

Trace a warning from source and channel through the receiver's attention, comprehension, beliefs, motivation and behaviour to find the stage at which it fails, then fix that stage.

The Communication-Human Information Processing model breaks a warning into communication stages (source, channel, delivery) and receiver stages: attention switch, attention maintenance, comprehension and memory, beliefs and attitudes, motivation, and behaviour. Each stage has known design factors, such as salience and placement for attention, signal words and explicitness for comprehension, familiarity for beliefs, and cost of compliance for motivation. Feedback loops run backwards, for instance repeated exposure produces habituation. Used investigatively, it stops teams assuming a bigger font is the fix when users in fact saw, read, understood and believed the warning but found compliance too costly. Evidence is gathered per stage, and the earliest failing stage is the bottleneck. For symbols, ANSI Z535.3 sets a target of 85 per cent comprehension and under 5 per cent critical confusions.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Define the warning, the hazard, the intended receivers (including the least able) and the target behaviour.
  2. Map the communication path: sources, channels and delivery routes.
  3. For each receiver stage list the design factors present or missing (salience, legibility, signal words, explicitness, familiarity, compliance cost).
  4. Gather evidence per stage: noticing during a realistic task (eye tracking or observation), comprehension tests and open-ended interpretation, belief and risk-perception questions, cost-of-compliance assessment and observed compliance.
  5. Locate the earliest failing stage and target the remedy there.
  6. Redesign and retest; for symbols aim for at least 85 per cent comprehension and under 5 per cent critical confusions.

Sources

  • Handbook of Human Factors and Ergonomics (Salvendy & Karwowski, 2021)

Also known as

  • C-HIP warning effectiveness analysis (Communication-Human Information Processing model)
  • C-HIP
  • C-HIP model
  • Warning bottleneck analysis

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error