Bottom-up vs. top-down perceptual flow

Description

Analyses how much users' perception of a screen is driven by the stimulus itself versus by their goals and expectations, and designs for both pathways.

Bottom-up processing is stimulus-driven: salient features capture attention regardless of goals. Top-down processing is driven by goals, knowledge and expectations, determining what users look for and how they interpret ambiguous information. Corbetta and Shulman linked these to dorsal (goal-directed) and ventral (stimulus-driven) attention networks. In interfaces, novices rely more on bottom-up cues while experts scan according to goals; unexpected critical events must break through top-down focus. This analysis compares where design puts bottom-up salience with where users' tasks direct top-down attention, using saliency maps and goal-driven eye-tracking data. Conflicts reveal where critical information is invisible to goal-driven users or where salient decoration hijacks attention.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Data
Mixed
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Generate bottom-up predictions with a saliency model or pre-attentive audit for key screens.
  2. Define user goals per task and the information each goal should lead users to.
  3. Run eye tracking with 10-15 participants in free-viewing and task-driven conditions on the same screens.
  4. Compare fixation patterns with saliency predictions; low correlation in task conditions indicates top-down dominance.
  5. Identify conflicts: critical but non-salient items missed in free viewing, and salient irrelevant items capturing fixations during tasks.
  6. Redesign so critical items are both salient and placed where goal-driven search expects them, then re-test.

Sources

  • Goldstein, E. B., Sensation and Perception
  • Gibson, J. J., The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception (1979)
  • Whalen, J., Design for How People Think (2019)
  • Sensation and Perception (Goldstein)
  • Ecological Approach to Visual Perception (Gibson)
  • Design for How People Think (Whalen)
  • The Inquiry Series, Ch 11 — Perception — Before Cognition

Also known as

  • Bottom-up/top-down processing analysis
  • Stimulus-driven versus goal-driven attention analysis

Categories

  • User Research
  • Cognitive Psychology & Perception