Bellotti's Five Questions for Sensing Systems

Description

Inspect a sensing or gestural design by asking how users address it, how it shows attention, what actions exist, how it responds and how accidents are handled.

Bellotti and colleagues argued that sensing systems lose the communicative cues that GUIs take for granted, so designers must answer five questions explicitly. Address: how does the user direct input to the system and not to something else? Attention: how does the system show that it is ready and attending? Action: what can be done and how are targets and operations specified? Alignment: how does the system respond and show that it is doing the right thing? Accident: how are errors avoided, and how can they be corrected or undone? Saffer recommends the questions as a completeness check on gestural interface documentation, alongside movement notation, because notation alone ignores the interplay between person and system. Used as an inspection, any question the design cannot answer marks a likely failure point.

Attributes

Loss type
Latent
Effort
Hours

Steps

  1. Assemble the design or specification of the sensing, voice or gestural system.
  2. Answer Address: how does the user direct input to this system rather than to others or to nothing?
  3. Answer Attention: how does the system signal that it is ready and attending?
  4. Answer Action: what can the user do, and how are targets and operations specified?
  5. Answer Alignment: how does the system respond and show that it understood?
  6. Answer Accident: how are errors avoided, detected and recovered from?
  7. Flag any question the design or documentation cannot answer and resolve it before testing.

Sources

  • Designing Gestural Interfaces (Saffer, 2008)

Also known as

  • Bellotti's Five Questions
  • Address, Attention, Action, Alignment, Accident
  • Making sense of sensing systems
  • Five A's

Categories

  • User Research
  • Usability & Evaluation