Becker-DeGroot-Marschak Willingness-to-Pay Auction

Description

Participants state a maximum price; a random price is drawn and they buy only if it is below their bid, making truthful reporting the best strategy.

Stated willingness to pay is inflated by hypothetical bias. In BDM, the participant states a bid; a price is drawn at random from a distribution; if the price is at or below the bid, the participant must buy at the drawn price (not the bid), otherwise not. Because the bid does not affect the price paid, the dominant strategy is to bid one's true valuation. With real money and real products, BDM yields incentive-compatible, individual-level WTP. Careful instructions and practice rounds matter because participants often misunderstand the mechanism. It gives UX and pricing research behavioural valuation data rather than survey hypotheticals.

Attributes

Loss type
Unmigrated
Effort
Weeks

Steps

  1. Define the product or feature and ensure it can actually be sold or delivered at the drawn price.
  2. Explain the mechanism clearly, with practice rounds using low-stakes items and comprehension checks.
  3. Collect bids, then draw the random price from a pre-announced distribution.
  4. Execute the transaction for winning bids so incentives are real.
  5. Analyse the distribution of WTP, build a demand curve and compare segments or product variants.
  6. Compare with stated WTP to estimate hypothetical bias for future surveys.

Sources

  • Becker, DeGroot & Marschak, Measuring utility by a single-response sequential method (1964), Behavioral Science
  • Wertenbroch & Skiera, Measuring consumers' willingness to pay at the point of purchase (2002), Journal of Marketing Research

Also known as

  • BDM
  • BDM mechanism
  • Incentive-compatible WTP elicitation

Categories

  • Analytics & Behaviour
  • Behavioral Science & Economics