Barrier Analysis (Hollnagel)

Description

Classifies the physical, functional, symbolic and incorporeal barriers that prevent harmful outcomes, evaluating their efficiency and weaknesses.

Hollnagel's Barriers and Accident Prevention, in the treatise's bibliography, classifies barrier systems as physical (block action), functional (preconditions such as interlocks or passwords), symbolic (require interpretation, such as warnings and labels) and incorporeal (rules, norms, training). Barriers are evaluated on efficiency, robustness, delay, resources needed, independence of human action and verifiability. Applied to UX, it audits the safeguards in a flow: is a destructive action prevented by a functional barrier (cannot proceed without condition) or merely a symbolic one (a warning users habituate to)? This helps designers choose the right strength of safeguard and avoid over-reliance on confirmation dialogs.

Attributes

Loss type
Siloed
Effort
Days

Steps

  1. Identify the harmful outcomes to prevent (data loss, wrong payments, privacy leaks).
  2. List existing barriers along each path to harm and classify them.
  3. Rate each barrier on efficiency, robustness, verifiability and dependence on user interpretation.
  4. Identify paths protected only by symbolic or incorporeal barriers.
  5. Propose stronger or complementary barriers proportional to risk.
  6. Test barrier effectiveness and habituation over time.

Sources

  • Lost Methods in UX — A Complete Treatise (Gopinath)
  • Hollnagel E (2004) Barriers and Accident Prevention. Ashgate
  • Haddon W (1973) Energy damage and the ten countermeasure strategies. J Trauma
  • CCPS & Energy Institute, Bow Ties in Risk Management (2018)
  • de Ruijter & Guldenmund, The bowtie method: A review (2016), Safety Science

Also known as

  • Barrier systems analysis
  • Safety barrier analysis
  • Bow-tie diagram
  • Barrier analysis
  • Bow-Tie Analysis

Categories

  • Accessibility
  • Human Factors & Error